For Reviewers

For Reviewers

Guidelines, expectations, and support for peer reviewers at StarNexus Science Press

Peer review is the cornerstone of academic integrity. At StarNexus Science Press, we deeply value the contributions of our reviewers. We are committed to providing a smooth, efficient, and rewarding review experience through our AI-enhanced OJS platform, clear guidelines, and responsive editorial support. Your expertise helps us maintain the highest standards of quality and rigor across all our journals.

Double-Blind Review AI-Powered Matching Structured Templates COPE Guidelines Reviewer Recognition

Peer Review Process

How the review workflow works from invitation to completion

1
Invitation

You receive an email invitation with manuscript details and deadline

2
Accept/Decline

Accept if you have the expertise and time. Decline with reason if unavailable

3
Review

Download the manuscript and use our structured template for your evaluation

4
Recommendation

Submit your review with a clear recommendation: accept, revise, or reject

5
Completion

The editor makes the final decision. You receive acknowledgment and recognition

Reviewer Guidelines

What we expect from reviewers and how we support you

Review Criteria

  • Originality and significance of the research
  • Clarity and quality of the writing
  • Methodological rigor and validity
  • Soundness of conclusions and interpretation
  • Ethical compliance and proper citations
  • Appropriateness for the journal's scope

Ethical Responsibilities

  • Maintain confidentiality at all times
  • Declare any conflicts of interest
  • Avoid personal criticism of the author
  • Do not use unpublished work for your own research
  • Follow COPE guidelines for ethical review
  • Respect author anonymity in double-blind review

AI-Powered Reviewer Matching

Our platform uses intelligent algorithms to match manuscripts with the most suitable reviewers

10,000+

Researcher profiles in our proprietary database

Google Scholar

Integrated data for global research visibility

AI Algorithms

Intelligent matching based on expertise and review history

The system continuously improves recommendations based on acceptance patterns, review quality, and response rates.

Reviewer Benefits & Recognition

Professional Development

Access to reviewer training resources, structured templates, and COPE-aligned guidelines to enhance your reviewing skills.

Recognition

Official acknowledgment on journal websites, and the option to have your reviewing activity credited on ORCID and Publons.

Networking

Opportunities to join editorial boards, connect with editors and fellow reviewers, and participate in academic events.

Frequently Asked Questions for Reviewers

How long do I have to complete a review?

The standard review deadline is 3-4 weeks from the date of invitation. If you need more time, please contact the editorial office to request an extension.

What should I do if I have a conflict of interest?

Decline the review invitation immediately and inform the editorial office of the conflict. Confidentiality is paramount.

Is the review process truly double-blind?

Yes. Author identities are hidden from reviewers and reviewer identities are hidden from authors throughout the process. The editorial team ensures all identifying information is removed before review.

Will I receive feedback on my reviews?

Yes. Editors may provide feedback on review quality. The journal also shares the final decision and author response to the review, helping you learn from the process.

How can I become a reviewer for StarNexus?

You can express interest by contacting the editorial office of any StarNexus journal. We welcome applications from active researchers with a doctoral degree and a strong publication record in their field.

Join Our Reviewer Community

We are always looking for qualified reviewers to support our journals and maintain the highest standards of academic integrity.

2026 StarNexus Science Press (Hong Kong). All rights reserved.

Published by the Greater Bay Area StarNexus Innovation Institute Limited, operating as StarNexus Science Press (Hong Kong), a non-profit academic publisher.

Contact: info@starnexus.press